Here we've got a cowboy tie, Morgan's ugly tie (traded with an African on his mission) and Michael's short tie.
These were the three finalists. Morgan and Michael were the final two and Morgan suggested a "walk-off" to help vote for the best ugly tie. They turned up the Halloween music and went at it. A video is posted below, sorry that it doesn't have any sound, but you'll get the picture. Despite the ugliness of Morgan's neon green tie Michael's short tie (and awesome walk-off) won the prize.